Why Revenue Bills Start In The House Of Representatives

But the senate may propose or concur with amendments as.

Why revenue bills start in the house of representatives. In this spirit the constitution allocates the power to raise revenue part of the power of the purse to the house of representatives the legislative body closest to the people. The house can also introduce bills pertaining to spending. Every member of the house of representatives was to be elected. Congress that s by design closer to the people with more frequent elections and smaller constituencies has outsized influence over revenue bills.

House of representatives is intended to ensure that the house remember that s the house of u s. If the senate generated revenue bills it could be viewed by citizens as taxation without representation since senators were not. Why revenue bills start in the house part 1 discusses the melding of philosophy and politics in 1787 that resulted in the origination clause. The requirement in the u s.

The second concerned the roles the house and senate would play in setting fiscal policy. Revenue bills were only to originate in the house because members of the house of representatives are the only federal officials elected directly by the people. Constitution that all spending bills originate in the u s. Employing gut and replace the senate takes a house originated revenue bill removes all of the house language keeps the house designated bill number and replaces the language with the senate s language.

All bills for raising revenue shall originate in the house of representatives. Relying on the rulemaking clause as a practical matter the senate originates bills to raise revenue. Because the constitution says they do article i section 7. At the convention the framers considered the extent to which the senate like the house of lords should be limited in its consideration of budget bills.

But the senate may propose or concur with amendments as on other bills constitution s origination clause. The first all bills for raising revenue shall originate in the house of representatives provided protections to both the people and the large states by having tax measures begin in the house with members most frequently elected and membership based on state population.